Monday 20 January 2014

Which one is better PV or Thermal?



The solar thermal water heating is now a temperamental thing. Water has a lot of weight, it expands when it freezes and it caused a severe damage to the pipes when it boils. On the other hand, the solar thermal systems are wonderfully efficient and many of the systems are able to work perfectly for over the decades but if the regular inspection is given to them. When the solar thermal system fails and it has been clear to some point of time that the solar thermal water heating is expected for the very-low heat usage like the solar pool heating companies are offering. 


For a long time, the wisdom has been shown the relative efficiency advantage of the solar thermal technology for the water heating which outweighs availability of the electric water heating. The capacity of the solar thermal to collect more energy is powering a conventional electric water heater alone with the solar thermal system.
There have been reductions in the solar electric (PV) costs and there has been a maturation of air-to-water heat pump technology as well, which have provided a new model which is solar-electric assisted heat pump water heating that has the fewest drawbacks other than the solar thermal. 

PV Advantages 

Lower cost – we have seen that the lowest cost has open the system with a proven results for the domestic water heating where the installation cost of the solar thermal has to based on the closed loop with the two tank system and has to be fully installed as well. The average cost for this system has to be designed for the family of four in a minimum range of the price tag for the residential applications.

The use of a heat pump water heater with an efficiency factor for about EF of 2.5 and an 1,800 kWh per year rating where the grid of 1 to 1.3 kW of PV has been added to an existing installation system in a region. 

Easier to install – A water heater can be replace by another single tank and you can add three to five additional modules in the PV system is really convenient instead of replacing the two tanks and the pipes, where the heat transfer fluid to the heavy rooftop should be pressure tested and has to be charged after installation. This can be result in less opportunity for the installation errors to be taken place. 

Less space usage – the solar thermal system requires a backup source where the two tanks are required, the one for the backup and the other one is for the solar system. You cannot save the space, while eliminating the usage of tank heaters as long as the tank heater can regulate the heat flow to the really low point as well in order to meet maximum demand. 



Low maintenance – Even when the solar thermal system has stopped working, but it does not fail to produce the energy. The electronic controller and the circulator pumps have to be inspected on the yearly basis, which assure that they are functioning properly and there should not be any scale of the system corrosion which may lead to the system failure. 

No comments:

Post a Comment